Comments on: Scott and Emma – Yuck!

By: I

Sat, 31 Dec 2011 01:43:45 +0000

Emma and Scott???? A big HELLNOO!!!!!!!!!! Jean and scott were so ment to be. Most emma lovers(ew) say that shes gorgeous, funny, sexy etc etc. But i thin she’s a cold ass whore! Ugh I despise the woman. Also honestly emma is not sexy unless you enjoy prostitutes, I mean the freaking corset gives any man an eyeful! Its disgusting and slightly disgracing. Jean was always modest but she still looked WAY more beautiful. Emma ruined everything, we need jean back pronto! On the other hand, scott is a douche bag who deserves heartbreak and to be left alone. Honestly, emma needs to leave and go screw someone else and scott should be left alone. He sgould beg on his knees for jean if she comes back. F**K emma -_- i soo hate her.

By: Saidi

Saidi — Wed, 31 Aug 2011 00:44:12 +0000

Okay I wish I could have seen this page earlier so I could give my opinion on it. Let’s go character by character shall we?

Cyclops: to everyone who says that Whedon & Morrison made him such a great character, I call BULLSHIT. I’ve read the new x-men run & the Scott in it was such a pathetic little bitch that it could make anyone wonder why this dude is in charge. As a straight male , I felt rather insulted that this guy is an “inspiration” because he’s so damn “charismatic” & then they made him worse. Him slobbering all over Hellfire Club Barbie over his wife’s freshly dug grave was intentional ( & the most disgusting of his transgressions);no reaction to his Dad dying, his brother and (genetic) daughter lost in space, and barely flinching over what? happens to his son’s death in X-Force #28,
Now if we’re talking about the Lobdell Nicieza Simonson version of Cyclops, Now we ‘d be talking!90′s cyclops was actually a lawgiver who had trouble relaxing, but he always? tried to do what’s best for the group and was always heroic when it counted , the fact that he went to the future 12 years to rise his son nathan along with jean or earned the respect of the acolytes while blindfolded is worthy of respect & his wedding with Jean had an actual logic behind it!
So I wish the 90′sCyclops appears & rips the Douchelops version’s nutsacks

Emma Frost: kind of the same case here.the real deal Emma has been squashed by quesada in generation X 75, since then we had Paris Hilton with a fake ID.

read Generation X & I swear to god guys,Morrison Emma is a downright insult to Gen X Emma. The former is just unlikeable cliched bitchy jean rival (how…neat..) while the latter is a classy,calculating , Subtle cold,independent, frightening ( the way she got rid of her sister or the detective was just scary…) & charismatic antiheroin who would never be the 2 dollar whore marvel keeps shoving down our throats)
If there’s any logical pairing here it’d be Iceman or Banshee. Morrison ruined what was one of my favourite antiheroins by taking away her subtlety.& the pairing with Scott makes no sense at all…

Jean Grey: I love Jean but it’s thanks to x-factor & the Lobdell /Nicieza run. I don’t care for Dark phoenix stuff & I HATE the “Jean is Phoenix ,goddess ” Bullshit! My Jean is just a powerful TK/ TP user that whoops your ass if you ever piss her off (the issue where she beats the hell out of Sabretooth, My 3rd Favourite X-men villain, Was the moment she went from a heroin I like to a heroin I LOVE!)

so there it is guys , my take on the matter. also Cable is awesome!

By: Aleks

Aleks — Sat, 23 Oct 2010 22:28:08 +0000

Scott can be with whomever he likes but i’m sure that when Jean returns they will resume their relationship in one way or another. He will not be able to help himself. Jean is his true love!

By: Elmo

Elmo — Thu, 05 Aug 2010 04:16:06 +0000

Scott and Emma?? HELL NO!! not because im a hater of Emma or a fan of Jean but its Jean who has been w/ Scott since the beginning of Xmen therefore it should be them as well near or in the end.. Emma has been turning cold to Scott lately so that could be a hint of the end of their relationship..

as far the idea where as Jean will be paired to Logan, well, there might be a possibility upon Jean’s return..

By: Donalyn

Donalyn — Sun, 13 Jun 2010 04:16:56 +0000

I like Jean and I like Emma. Scott had a very long and meaningful relationship with Jean, but it ended and he moved on with Emma. Its a done deal unless they break up. I think that this should be the chance for Jean to finally move on to someone else like Logan. She needs more character growth. She needs to be a little more relatable too.

By: Bill

Bill — Sat, 12 Jun 2010 00:26:49 +0000

I’m not real fond of Scott/Emma. They have their moments but they’re very hit or miss. Got to agree with another user, the whole notion that Scott & Jean’s relationship was just puppy love that ran too long is bull-s***. How did they go from being a love that defied death itself to just being overlong puppy love? What about Kitty Pryde & Colossus, is that just puppy love?

Even sadder, there was no real reason to destroy Scott & Jean’s relationship other than Morrison had a hard on for Emma and Quesada hated Jean and hates any hero having a relationship that isn’t ultra-screwed up (though there were writers even before hand who intentionally or not demonized & vilified the relationship between Scott & Jean) or isn’t a single swinging bachelor.

By: 576

576 — Mon, 07 Jun 2010 19:37:16 +0000

I can understand why you and many others don’t like this couple and I respect your opinion. I just wanted to explain why I DO love this couple.
Firs of all – answering the question of Emma’s self-respect – she turned into the Phoenix on their sessions to seduce Scott and to have fun. She admitted never having real feelings towards him at the beginning of the affair. However – there is at least one scene of Scott and Emma kissing while she was herself – blond and all. (New X-Men v1 #136). After Jean discovered the affair, she saw the truth in Emma’s mind and recognised true love there – you believe the Phoenix has the power to do that, don’t you? Because if it can’t, no one can. Also, Emma admitted true feelings towards Summers to Wolverine and in her own arc in “X-Men – Manifest Destiny #2″, she had no one to lie to about that, it was the issue based on her thoughts. In that issue she tells that she doesn’t deserve Cyclops and even has a nervous breakdown. During the whole “Divided we Stand” story she is very upset that Scott doesn’t tell her a secret he’s hiding that practically eats him alive, and she has hundreds of chances to read his mind or make him open the “box” with the secret within his mind – but she decides to let him ruin the relationship instead because she doesn’t want to poke around in hi head without his permission.
As of Cyclops’s feelings – there are certain moments, too. First of all we have to agree that he wasn’t in love with Emma until she basically destroyed him in “Astonishing X-Men”. He was angry with her but when he realized she risked her life for the X-Men when she was driven insane by Cassandra Nova, he fell in love with her and admitted it right in the middle of the fight, which surprised her a whole lot. He’s been saying it ever since. Other highlights: Scott forcing Emma to share their darkest criminal secrets and saying that he still loves her and that if everyone else kick them out he wouldn’t care. Scott telling the X-Men that Emma is a powerful telepath that he loves and cannot stop if it comes to that. Or his thinking about her in “Cable #6″, saying to himself that he knows she will never look into his mind without his consent. Or the whole “Phoenix Endsong” thing – he wasn’t even tempted to tell Jean anything about love, you can say it’s because Jean was the Phoenix at that time, but it didn’t stop him from kissing Emma and hugging her and smiling at her when she was Phoenix for a short time, even if it was very inappropriate at that moment. Or “Phoenix Warsong” – he told Emma that he can’t help loving her, he just doesn’t trust her.
I’m not even counting the whole other universes where they had children or were married (in the House of M he could have anything he desired deeply, he didn’t want to marry Jean, he was with Frost), or when Emma seduced him in the Exiles v4, or even where he killed himself in “Astonishing X-Men: Ghost Boxes” because Emma was dead and he “was coming to her” (c).

I only named the moments I remembered, there are many other things that show that their love is true and not faked. I just want to ask you not to judge the book by it’s cover – if you don’t read the comics, how can you ever know it this couple is something true? I read anything there is about them – their fights, him even calling her a “sick bitch” once, her ignoring him, his sleeping on a couch. But they are funny and beautiful together, I’m sorry that you can’s see it, but I understand how bad it is to lose your favorite couple if you’re a Jean/Scott fan. But don’t you think it’s time?.. It’s been what, 10 years now? Jean was resurrected once during that time and Scott had plenty of chances to tell her he loves her – he didn’t. It’s just over. Emma is a great person, I’m glad she exists, it’s a shame that she is hated so much.

By: jess

jess — Tue, 04 May 2010 19:24:50 +0000

Emma just seems so fake to me for some reason. I have to admit i stopped reading x-men after Grant Morrison. That’s how much i hate what he did to the characters. Picked up when joss was writing then left if again. But it seems that when i grab a graphic novel.. she is always like “oh i love it when u are like this blah blah”. Wouldn’t surprise me if she fakes it. Sorry Scott!

As far as Emma no longer controlling him mentally. Yep it did not start on the right foot. Then jean making Scott go to Emma to prevent some terrible future. How convenient eh? Makes me doubt this relationship tremendously. Now as for her having little self respect…um..when she was having this so called affair. I’m sorry.. psychic affair. Why was she dressing up as phoenix and made her hair red? Oh. Because Scott likes her like that. In that issue of endsong did she not tell him “i know u think of her”. Even though they then try to establish as Scott wanting Emma. Now. Jean has been dead for a while so it would only be natural for Scott to have developed some feelings for her. But to claim that Scott and Jean’s relationship was just puppy love. And that Emma is the love of Scott’s life… please. That’s where i lose the little respect that i have for this relationship.

It is not common especially nowadays to bump into ppl that are married for years and years. It is extremely rare. But everyone (i don’t care who u are) likes to see a romance that lasts. That is why superman has Louis. And Mr. Fantastic has the invisible woman. Scott and Jean were like that. They were one of the most popular couples out there. I really think it is just a matter of time. Before someone says.. um.. why did we do that. Um. For the same reason we gave them leather costumes to make them more mysterious and realistic. So what’s up with the big bright X? Er..well. And why is beast dressed up as the beast from “Beauty and the Beast”? I could go on and on.

By: 576

576 — Thu, 08 Apr 2010 20:43:32 +0000

Why do I get the feeling that almost every Jean/Scott fans have no idea what Scott and Emma’s relationship looks like? Like they never read the comics. They probably still think Emma is controlling Scott mentally, that she is a replacement for Jean. Do you think Emma has so little self-respect to ever consider being in THAT kind of a relationship? Look at her – you think a man can not be crazy about her? Seriously?..
The thing Scott and Emma share is pure, funny as it sounds, with him being so boring and plain, with her being so bitchy and cruel and cold – they love each other and it’s a very sincere, soft feeling they are not afraid to show each other.
They are also very sexy together, very tactile. Emma has made a happy man out of Scott, she made him strong, manly, made him fight and win and think and try to be better. She teases him, she questioned him, she forces him to face things he is afraid to face. He is not a boy that loved a beautiful girl named Jean. He is a grownup man who loves, has constant sex with, respects and needs a grownup woman named Emma Grace Frost. It’s a great change, it’s one of the best things that happened in Marvel universe and one of the things that changed the most.

By: dg

dg — Mon, 22 Mar 2010 12:41:59 +0000

The problem is only – Scott loves Emma) So you’re gonna have to suck it up. Emma has style, she is sexy, cold, smart and interesting. If Summers loved Jean he would tell it to her when she was dying on his hands. People who call Emma a whore amuse me – she slept with Shaw, Namor and Tony Stark, but between these man there were long periods of time. AND IT ALL OUTSIDE THE HOLY BOUNDS OF MARRIAGE! I mean, what a bitch, right? If you call it being a whore you should talk to your grandparents about that, they will be proud of you.)
Too bad for Emma haters – she is amazing, she is the most beautiful woman of Marvel Universe, so what that she had plastic surgery? She wanted to be her best at everything and she is a perfection. She certainly doesn’t anyone’s approval. She has Scott)